Probably not. I was just answering the question that was asked of me...who would I rather see.

But Wiig looks old.

Much younger comedic actresses, like a Riki Lindhome or Abbi Jacobson or Kate Micucci (but not Ilana Glazer).

It's not that complicated. Neither Wiig nor McCarthy have ever made me laugh.

No. It's knowing that neither Wiig nor McCarthy are funny. And knowing they'll have write fat jokes just to try and make McCarthy funny. I've never even heard of the other two women and don't care enough to google them. Also, Wiig looks unsettingly mannish in that photo.