philyg
PhilyG
philyg

I’m sure he also doesn’t want to watch the show. If someone crapped on my books that I spend years writing and are critically acclaimed I would also hate watching it.

Robbs wife is still alive in the books although she has a completely different name. different backstory and different house.

Benioff and Weiss have proved over and over again that they have no interest in retelling Martins story so the fact that he’s dead in the books doesn’t mean anything for the show.

I’d love to give Benioff and Weiss some credit for including the gravedigger since it’s really important to Sandors developent but I just can’t. They can’t just butcher every good thing there is in the books, change a lot of stuff, most of it being unnecessary changes, and then stay true to the books they were

But was there a “people rising from the dead to come kill you” a problem in this instance.

What has the world come to when you have to defend yourself by saying you’ve never read the books just because you just critisized the show?

Jon is a bastard, Jon just came back from the dead and Jon just had had ass beaten and had to be saved by a foreign army. That’s not the stuff of kings.

I’m sorry but this is just stupid. Do you honestly believe that the show will answer any of the questions you’ve been waiting on the books to answer? Only the books can do that because only they are canon. Nothing against the show, bless everyone who still thinks it’s a good thing on its own, but it has strayed way to

This is the stupidest thing I have read all day. Season 5 was so god damn terrible with its own story that is surpassed the books there. Even season 4 was badly adapted.