No. Some like myself have speculated based on various things, but so far just speculation. And some of it is based on stuff that I got wrong anyway (I thought there was a bullet hole in her window).

The only thing I even know about Tarantino in regards to Lynch was his hypocritical peacocking about how awful FWWM was, so I wonder if he ever has any opinions on Roth and JJL in this. I generally enjoy their scenes but mostly because I tend to see them as more of the rictus grin merriment surrounding the mostly grim…

Definitely. I just didn't think they'd resolve it - I thought she would be presumed to have passed away after the finale.

This was probably the most I've enjoyed the Roadhouse in that we got to see that little glimpse of complete absurdity with the chart and the extended dramatic intro for a ZZ Top song. I kept waiting for them to appear.

I've read all kinds of theories about her - that she's just another example of the toll drugs have taken on the town, that she was reacting to Becky being killed, that she was getting the Log Lady powers now that Margaret is gone. My personal guesses were that she is Judy or that she is a manifestation of Audrey…

My opinion isn't based on 2017 requirements. They are actually based on comparing the show to the original. I've defended the show quite a bit when people talk about the treatment of women and also when fans have gone wholesale into ugly attacks against women who don't fit their standards (like Audrey or Tammy, among…

Beyond the stuff people have already picked over like the violence, I mostly mean things like women having a narrative point of view, which they hadn't had much of for most of the season compared to the original show. That's changed a bit in the last few weeks and it's why I was pleased to see a lot of this 'triangle'…

Oh that's right. I forgot about that. I just thought it might have been more because of the gun, Steven's despair, and Carl's fears in the closeup shot.

James was always a bit slow, but they mentioned in the first episode that he's struggled after a motorcycle accident. I think he is just more awkward and flustered than anything else. I thought James Marshall did a good job in that scene, as he has in all his appearances this season.

For all of the revival's issues with writing for women, I was very pleased that Nadine was the one to mature enough to cut the cord with Ed. It is the only way it could be, because Ed never could have - not only because of his guilt over what had happened to her, but also because she was a crutch he used to avoid…

Annie exists in some way, because Hawk and Frank mentioned her when they talked about Cooper going to the Lodge. But they don't seem to actually remember her or that Norma was her sister. That's why some of us thought there were alternate timelines.

I had a tough time getting through the Log Lady scenes. I wasn't expecting them to have the character herself die. I thought she may always linger on, as a tribute. How harrowing, and yet how very brave, to see Catherine Coulson talking about dying and how death was just another chapter. Knowing she passed away not…

How can James not be cool? He's so awesome his friend left two people with permanent, crippling injuries just to protect him.

That's the vibe I got too when we saw the bullet hole in the window. It would also fit together with various other things (Becky giving major Laura Palmer vibes, and her last scene being the heartwarming conversation with Shelly about eating ice cream). I'm not sure I care enough about Becky to really react, but I…

I saw someone saying that Lynch had literally made Bowie a Tin Machine. It made me smile.

It's interesting how all the soap content that was the bread and butter of the original show is now mostly given to the oldest characters like Norma and Ed. Shelly and Bobby, who are in the mid-age range, have had a bit, but also a lot of drama with the town (Bobby) or with Becky's many dramas (Shelly). The young…

I think it's probably one of those things that he has blocked out or pushed down because so much else happened at that time (Laura died, his relationship with Shelly blew up repeatedly, and not long after, his father died). I agree it's an odd fit with the more positive Bobby we've seen in the revival, but then we've…

I wonder about Becky too…

One of the most honest parts of the revival. And one of the most unappreciated.

I read some review a few days ago from someone who said they were a Twin Peaks fan, not a David Lynch fan, and how upset they were over how the revival degraded Hawk, Andy and Lucy. My eyes went back in my head.