In the end, Sam gave Dean his agency back very, very quickly AND reiterated his belief in Dean and allowed him to make his own choice. Don't give me that crap about how it was only to make Sam sympathetic. It's canon. Dean took away Sam's agency without his knowledge and lied to him for months while having no issue…

If I had to lose who I was to get a "happy" ending, by someone else's definition, I would be furious. In other words, I would not consent to a lobotomy that would remove my memories of people I love, and things that changed me and made me a person who liked myself and who others liked just to keep me alive. I wouldn't…

Except she was kind of clear that she would rather die than lose what she had learned and gained, and it should have been her choice.

I don't know. Considering the guy she fell in love with in The Library was actually real, I think they could have had a far better ending than losing everything she gained. Sarah Jane didn't really want to leave either and The Doctor just pretty well shoved her out the door, so it could have been done with Donna.

I'm with you on hating what happened to Donna. It was cruel and unnecessary.

I just rewatched. Sara collapses in Nyssa's arms. Sara's parents come running in and Nyssa tells Sara if she wants to be with her parents so much they will be together in eternity. Oliver shoots her with an arrow, epic fight scene. Nyssa ends up outside on pier still trying to kill Oliver. Oliver tells her there is…

Considering Sara dragged herself practically from her death bed to tell Oliver to not kill Nyssa, I don't think that's the message. I really felt like if Sara could have Nyssa without the killing people part, she would have been good.

Sorry, but Cas found Dean, beat him to a pulp and locked Dean in the panic room. Sam let him go because he believed in him. So no Sam gave Dean his agency back.

Actually he said that in the exact circumstances (AKA Dean dying and the only way to save him is to violate his wishes) Sam would honor what Dean wanted. Remember season three? Remember Doc Benton the Frankenstein
Zombie? Sam wanted to take Doc Benton's formula to keep Dean alive forever and keep him from Hell. Dean…

The thing is that way back in season one when Sam thought he could get out they had a similar talk in Salvation, I think. At that time Sam was being as reassuring as possible. He told Dean that he wanted to go back to his life once the demon (who was still the thing that killed Mom and Jess) was dead but it didn't…

I know, as soon as I saw the museum guy I thought "that's the guy who did it", because God Forbid! they talks to an expert in a field who isn't the guilty party (remembering the math expert from last year).

Although you may be right about the smashing being interrupted, it was still fairly unintelligent to do it there. Steal the rock and smash it at home. Heck stow it away so when you die and your reputation won't be ruined it can be unveiled and science can go forward.

once the verdict came down from FBI brass that Neal’s sentence wouldn’t
be lifted (Peter’s really got to stop making promises he can’t keep) Just to note, Peter wasn't responsible for making a promise he couldn't keep. Last week Neal told Peter that he had contacted a lawyer about getting out of his probation and the…

The two things I never really forgave from the Davies era. What 10 did to Harriet Jones, because 9 had already said that she was destined to oversee the Golden Age of the British Empire and then 10 changed that fixed point in time because he had a snit that she didn't do what he told her to. I felt she was right, she…

I think Jared does a fine job of playing all the facets of Sam.

I suppose, but he just tells Cas to leave the pimp mobile, and have Cas drive the classic car back, then take Cas to his car when it's all over. It's not like we see Cas in his car again.

I disagree with you on Jared's performance. I think he's been doing a great job juggling the different characters he plays.

I think Sam getting the Impala would be more out of character and really Sam deserves SOMETHING, Dean shouldn't get it all. It was sad that they had to walk to get gas to Cas's car. It's such a shame they don't have a bunker with multiple classic cars in the garage so they could take one of those when they need a…

Only that gag gets whatever limited laughs it has in it from the fact
that most males don’t make very attractive females (at least, most males
dressing up as females for comedic purposes, excepting Dave Foley and
honestly Jack Lemmon)

I admit I didn't watch this one. I am one of the few people who doesn't find the Slaps funny any more. They were funny the first time and the unplanned one at Barney's theater performance. But the slow, torturing buildup ever since the first Slapsgiving just bothers me. I know most fans love it, but I just don't.