Show us even ONE place in Cosmos where they said that a discovery debunked God. You can't because they didn't. In fact, this show been VERY clear about not ruling out God.

Believing in a Creator is not necessarily the same as creationism. Creationism says the Earth is about 6,000 years old and that God created humans in their present form. Do you believe that? If so, you are NOT a scientist. But if you believe in evolution and the Big Bang AND you think a creator could have started it…

Should the reviewer also disregard his opinions of every other episode of the show so far? Or can you give us a list of the episodes about which his opinion is irrelevant here? Or is it just the opinion about the first D&D episode you want left out of the review? Either way makes NO sense. OF COURSE the reviewer's…

For all our sakes, please revamp the grades to actually mean something.

The change with Frasier wasn't because the show runners lacked memory. That was an intentional change as they revamped the character to be the center of his own show. BIG difference between that and what Brian Arsenault rightly criticized.

This review demonstrates what Todd does that earns him some of the backlash. As usual, the first couple of paragraphs read like someone's LiveJournal ramblings, and then he snaps into succinct/clear writer mode as if he suddenly remembers that other people are reading.

Um…that's not dumbing down. It's a rather well-known and fondly remembered quote from Carl Sagan that has been around for more than 30 years. It is being a bit poetic, and it's a direct quote from the original COSMOS. And if you listened, Tyson very clearly explains how we are made of various atoms that were created…

Marshall reacted to the idea of having a daughter, not to Lily's "won't be eligible to be President" line, so what gives you the idea he'd be a bad judge?

Using a double hyphen (—) as an em dash is, again, standard usage. Not knowing that shows that you lack enough knowledge about em dashes and the like to be having this conversation.

Um…then it hasn't lost its charm for the masses. That's kind of what charm is all about. If the masses still like a show, it hasn't lost its charm for most people. Sorry it has for you, and I definitely am less charmed than in middle seasons. (or perhaps you are using 'charm' in an unusual way…)

But the point of this episode was that Howard wasn't learning from his mistake—that is, going to space. He didn't make mistakes as an astronaut. He did a fine job, remember? He simply hated EVERY SINGLE SECOND of the experience. Howard was miserable every time we saw him in space (or preparing to go), even though he…

It's fine to quibble, but you should be correct in your quibbles. Not having spaces between em dashes and words is standard usage in American English. You may think it looks awful—so this probably bugs you—but it is correct usage NOT to use spaces.