His Six Feet Under and  Rome episodes were good to great from what I remember…

I don't know about Buck, looking at the episodes he wrote for Six Feet Under and first few seasons of Dexter he's not that bad…

This is AVclub, people act here like their sh!t doesn't stink. But trusting IGN comment section or their review is not good idea either. And not saying Seasons 5 and 6 are the worst Dexter has to offer is just dumb.

You can't go from pleasing the first half to hating the second half that quickly. I mean, if the premiere was A- then the finale can't be C-, and vice a versa. the quality/nonquality was on similar level all season long.

You can't go from pleasing the first half to hating the second half that quickly. I mean, if the premiere was A- then the finale can't be C-, and vice a versa. the quality/nonquality was on similar level all season long.

Yeah luckily Season 2 of Homeland didn't show weaknesses and kept Homeland as the best show on TV. There really weren't signs of crap on horizon last 4-5 episodes…
If it did we could really speculate on it's future, but this way there's no point.
So you're right, as always.
Really.

Yeah luckily Season 2 of Homeland didn't show weaknesses and kept Homeland as the best show on TV. There really weren't signs of crap on horizon last 4-5 episodes…
If it did we could really speculate on it's future, but this way there's no point.
So you're right, as always.
Really.

Funny how everyone hates the show once again…I predict in two years you will be on this same page with god almighty Homeland. A.V. Club you just funny…(+ it wouldn't be a classic Showtime series if fans didn't turn on it)
But I have to say it, I like it. There, I said it.
Was it sometimes nonsensical? Yes.
Do I care? No.
W…

Funny how everyone hates the show once again…I predict in two years you will be on this same page with god almighty Homeland. A.V. Club you just funny…(+ it wouldn't be a classic Showtime series if fans didn't turn on it)
But I have to say it, I like it. There, I said it.
Was it sometimes nonsensical? Yes.
Do I care? No.
W…

You just can't get enough of bashing, do you?

You just can't get enough of bashing, do you?

Sorry, according to my opinion, it was on the other way from C.

Sorry, according to my opinion, it was on the other way from C.

I am on the same ship, I like this season more than last three, but it has no chance against the craft of the first season or thrill of the second. So it's more or less in the third place with third season.

I am on the same ship, I like this season more than last three, but it has no chance against the craft of the first season or thrill of the second. So it's more or less in the third place with third season.

Was this episode really that qualitatively different than some from the beginning of the season? Was it really almost D material? I thought last week that the grade is little harsh but this is just silly. I mean, if this deserves C-, than that last few episodes last year should go beyond F.
I would like to see Alston's…

Was this episode really that qualitatively different than some from the beginning of the season? Was it really almost D material? I thought last week that the grade is little harsh but this is just silly. I mean, if this deserves C-, than that last few episodes last year should go beyond F.
I would like to see Alston's…

Perhaps not the best night for Showtime's dramas…

Perhaps not the best night for Showtime's dramas…

He said something similar in the first season, so what are you doing here now after six years?