I like this idea. I don’t think it will happen (too sensitive information), but I like it very much.

Not necessarily. Aegon the Conqueror had two wives at the same time and his sons from both unions inherited the throne, so they were both legitimate. If Rhaegar married Lyanna, Jon may be legitimate even if he was still married to Elia, too. Of course, legitimacy might not matter all that much, anyway, since “power…

Nope. Jon is King in the North because the Northerners made him so.

We don’t know that Dany can’t have children. There’s a whole theory about that, go check it out. It actually makes a lot of sense (unlike some theories :) ).

There is no need for him to annul his previous marriage, there was precedent of Targaryen kings being married to more than one woman at a time; he children of both unions were legitimate and, in fact, both ascended to the throne after their father.

Em... how shall I say this, might she be persuaded to send those baby quilts on to me, maybe? ;)

I’m very sorry for your loss. I hope you’re doing ok and have support to help you through it. Next time, though, I’d just say that out loud - it would definitely be very educational. I wish you all the best!

Chill out, it’s just opinion. How lucky are we, we have both! Those who prefer the books have the books, and those who prefer the show can watch the show. Why do we keep arguing?! I prefer the books; I think the show is good; I can see why many people prefer the show; how does their preferring the show make my…

I think he’ll finish WoW but not DoS. I’m heartbroken about it and am still hoping, but if I’m sincere with myself I know GRRM won’t finish the saga. It makes me so sad :(

I’m going to be wildly off-topic here, but where do you stand on the immigration debate? Does the same rule apply?

This, exactly! I have no problem with Ed Sheeran as a cameo but the way it’s been done makes it look as though he’s the POV character and Arya is the cameo :D

I don’t know how average looking they’d be, since they’re the most likely to be well fed and safer from injury and disease than peasants. Plus they have little else to do than take care of their looks, it’s actually expected of them.

I don’t have a problem with a young girl who is also a strong leader, but the way Lady Mormont is portrayed in the show is such a caricature it’s hard for me to watch. It’s not the fact that a character such as hers exists, it’s the fact they went cartoonishly over the top with “look, she’s such a badass.”

Argh, I can’t stand the character. I actually flinched through the scene where she was introduced. It was so painfully pandering and unrealistic and over the top. She’s the ultimate trope and I still flinch every time she comes on screen.

I’m good, then, because I disliked Arya from the first and had a soft spot for Sansa; she annoyed me often, but I never stopped liking her.

Brienne? Shireen? Selyse? Grown-up Lysa Arryn? Most Frey girls? Penny? Pretty Merris? Even Arya in the beginning? I think there are roughly as many ugly ones as beautiful ones, but most are somewhere in between. Of course if the setting is a prestigious brothel (Chataya, Alayaya etc.), most girls are going to be…

Except in the book Catelyn judges it good sense that Robb keeps his wife’s brother out of Lord Walder’s sight when they came to the wedding. Bringing his wife to the wedding would have been an incredibly poor political move, so in short, stupid.

How were they any better born than Shireen Baratheon and Margaery Tyrell? Assuming you talk unmarried ladies, otherwise there’s several more.

I live in a 690 sq foot two bedroom apartment with my husband and two kids O_o OK, there’s a hectare of living room outside our front door, but still :D

That doesn’t work for me because I eat healthily, just too much. So I just end up overeating (I can easily have 5 apples in a row, for example).