It’s not about how I looked at it. It’s what he always said.

And let’s find the thousands of people who had issues (and still bitch about issues) with how Superman was portrayed in MoS and BvS...and see if we can find a venn diagram of the same people who are fine with what went on in this flick with Luke.

HAHA. No they aren’t. They are overwhelmingly positive with regards to TLJ. Dissenters are shown the fucking door with prejudice. Every damned day. Look at ANY TLJ post, and the first/most voted post is usually one disparaging anyone from having an negative view of TLJ. Check out Aiwasz’s post on the earlier TLJ post…

They have indeed. Which bothers me because Thrawn is the PERFECT post-Palpatine main villain for the series to have explored in the sequel trilogy, a military genius who really COULD best a New Republic...and they didn’t, but threw him into Rebels instead. And we instead get Fake-Palpatine (Snoke), and…

Right, because It’s obviously me who misconstrued the episodes of Clone Wars and not you. Man, fuck off with your constant attacks. I get it, you think I suck and I’m wrong. Great. Enjoy that, and bugger off unless you want to have an adult discussion. This is tedious at this point.

Ruins nothing. My rant stands.

Sorry, George didn’t consider anything officially “canon” in the EU before the reset. Just his films, and the existing (at the time) animated show (The Clone Wars). They existed in a nebulous “sort of canon” arena, where things got played with a lot but nothing ever was solidified. Trust me, old school EU fan here who…

Cool, cool.

Considering Pablo says random shit like “I don’t like Lightsaber forms because they weren’t designed by Nick Galliard (lightsaber fight choreographer) and thus should not be a canon aspect”...I feel like he’s a tad jaded about anything he didn’t come up with.

Not when one canon piece of material (Clone Wars S6) contradicts what TLJ did here. That’s an inconsistency.

Metaphor? no, Luke did indeed “cut himself off from the force” in TLJ. It’s why his sister (who he had a strong bond with) didn’t know how to find him in TFA, or why he didn’t know Han had died till Chewie showed it on his face.

The EU was largely non-canonified unless George wanted to use something from it (Like Quinlan Vos). He always regarded it as cool, but non-canon ish...I get what you are saying though.

It most certainly does not.

All fair. Thanks for being a voice of reasoned discussion in a sea of people telling me I’m wrong or a raging fanboy. :) It’s refreshing.

Except that merely masks Yoda...he was still abel to use the force. He did not disconnect from it. TLJ has Luke disconnecting from it entirely, to the point that not even force ghosts could contact him, or his sister...

Jesus, you people. Obi-Wan was not the only one who reported the Force that way, so did every other Jedi master. Everyone who has come at me with “Obi-Wan lies” with regards to what he says the force is...hasn’t watched any other Jedi speak about it,...apparently.

It’s interesting how you don’t actually rebut my comments, you just say I’m wrong and think that will fly. Okay man.

Am I? For having a problem with the screwy internal consistency of a story? Okay, sure.

Incorrect. The Sith mask their connection to the dark side (Palpatine did this), but they do NOT disconnect from it...otherwise they would not be able to USE their force powers.

And the fact that the creator of the entire shebang, disagrees with it? Should that stand for something?