What Bojack did to Penny feels different to me in part because he wasn’t anywhere near as under the influence as he was when Sarah Lynn died or when he choked Gina. He’s responsible for creating the conditions in which those things happened, but it’s not like he intended for Sarah Lynn to die, or decided to choke Gina…

I just finished season 6 and am reading through these reviews for memory refreshment and because I can’t get enough. You’ll be pleased to know that this “plot-hole” has been closed, thanks to a gag which turns out to be a call-back to this very thing. Diane’s parents DIDN’T name her for the first four years of her…