I’m sorry Caroline but NOTHING worked about James in season one. From the shitty office romance to the love triangle and him being an ass to his girlfriend. He’s one of the WORST written characters in the arrowverse.

You made my day with this.

And there was some guy who predicted that they may be in The Bad Place here in the comments section last year! Man we AV-Club commenters are smart!

Booo! I need nightwing man!

Bet the audition went: “Hmm, good acting Brenton, now turn around and show us that booty”