Hmm, I think it should've been done like an "appeal", first she steps back, but then she tries to appeal to him / talk sense into him, like "I can't follow you there, you know that right?", not necessarily calmed down but changed breath or cadence.

"how borderline unhinged Christensen seems while conveying Anakin's fall to the Dark Side with how Hamill plays Luke's near fall to the Dark Side. Christensen in "Sith" seems like he is losing his mind with rage. Luke should have seemed almost the same in "Jedi" when Vader and the Emperor goad him into losing his cool…

""Everything he writes between Anakin and Padme is in the faux-poetic style". This is where Lucas gets himself into the most trouble. It's how he got Anakin's infamous "I don't like sand" line—again, that's the sort of line that must be hell for an actor to deliver."

"but since she just said, "you're breaking my heart", Lucas was just wrong to put the line there."
Seen the Machinist? When Bale gets unhinged, the hooker gets pissed for a second, but then calms down for a short moment and tries to reason with him - which doesn't work, and that's when she really loses it.

"No, "path I can't follow" is just more awkward Lucas dialog getting in the way of the performance."
There's nothing awkward about it, it just ought not to be delivered while sounding spontaneous while choking on tears - if she starts this little "soliloquy" following a spontaneous and unfiltered breakdown, it…

Well, heartbroken is the general emotion, exasperated is the way said grief is expressed, i.e. on the verge of tears, accelerated breathing.

Well it is exactly great, so your statement is stupid :)

Well that's what I'm saying, so many child actors, and all of them good - now does that sound like an amazing coincidence, or rather look like you can find good child actors if you look?

Lol, what fucking vapid comment is that?

Well, for one the general reception was above average, and secondly, mediocre kind of implies finding "positives" is really easy.

Alright there, isn't her delivery of "killed younglings", "because of what you've done", of "path I can't follow" a bit very unconvincing, though?

Okay, so would "laughingstock" be more appropriate?

Well of course! Had to point out that you were clown, after all.

"The fan edits I've seen made me appreciate the good parts,"
That's quite lame of you that it took you that.

What is it with you clowns quoting entirely normal sounding lines and then claiming there's some kind of problem?

"Mr. Plinkett's ninety minute theses of the prequels completely disproves this article one hundred percent,"
Ow wow really.

I'm not sure who Kyle Newman is, but there are two camps in the SW fandom that are opposed to each other, and equally unreasonable.

4u.

"what-so-ever."
That's the bit that cemented your clown status - not taking you seriously at least since now, kthnx..

"The droid army was simply comic relief and I think that was a HUGE mistake….. Things would have been MUCH better if they were portrayed as an actual dangerous enemy"