That line sounded like a reference to a specific study on false memories, where participants where shown four photos of their childhood but one of them was photoshopped to suggested a fictional event and 50% of them created memories around the false photo and invented more information and details each time they saw it…

You're right it makes more sense that he is dead, but I can only see this leading to Will being further adrift and I dont like that, which is silly of course to expect a happy ending from all this

Same here, too many doctors and I wanted to see Gideon again

I also found the live surgery even more troubling than the totem pole or angels which I think is to the credit of the three actors excellent performances in the scene.

For once I get the relevance of the episode title, a Roti is potato shredded and then moulded back together.
I hope that Gideon does survive because I like the idea that Will held onto himself, even under enormous stress, enough that he managed to incapacitate someone without killing, again.

Snow knows nothing but surely he isn't that dumb? Ygritte is kind of a badass so the only thing that makes sense is he had always planned to break up with her but still cared about her so he made sure she didn't kill any wildings so she still had a chance of rejoining them.
Unless he is still such a fucking patriarchal…

I just want a season 3 walk through already

I know nothing about the cost of producing a show but I'm really surprised that this show is cheap to make, the last episode apparently blew $2000 just on a leg of iberico ham, sets and costume are immaculately detailed and with makeup and special effects every episode looks like a short movie.
How is it cheap compared…

No it's just The John

That why the 80s sucked tho

You should probably check out 'Til Death, it's not a good show at all but over 4 season it basically does what you describe.

No, if they listened to the fans they would have not fired Harmon, given the show Six season and a movie and Season 4 would have started October 19 like they said and a lot of other things like a better time slot.

Maybe in the background while your doing something else

You know I never considered that, maybe the show runner and two major collaborators and half a season earlier two other major collaborators leaving didn't alter the show at all, but through magic it changed my brain and turned me against something I loved, yeah that must be it.

No the perfect timeline was no dice roll and Jeff getting the pizza, 1 is Annie getting the pizza and not much happening. the darkest is 5, troy getting the pizza.
The significance of the 1, I dont know, maybe the writers are saying S4 took place in the timeline where Annie got the pizza which you might consider…

Am I the only one who misses Starburns?

That seems unlikely? Only Rash would know but referencing the common moment that occurs in many body swap movies where junk is checked or boobs are grabbed vs a relatively obscure youtube clip (750,000 is a lot but still less than half the community audience) I'm going with a nod to the movie trope.
Also it's the least…

Considering that he got material from people failing to pay their storage unit costs he might have had reason to be paranoid about an automated system he might forget or lose access to. 
Or maybe it was just a necessary plot device.

I said I wouldn't comment again but I actually watched this episode since it was Rash and everyone seemed to like it so I couldn't resist giving my opinion once more.

Yeah I agree that the concept is scary, maybe it was that the Doctor and Claras survival is assured (well Clara could conceivable die and come back and I think she is actually behind Rory in deaths per episode) and every other character is a one note archetype or faceless red shirt so there is no tension in seeing…