then why in the last film of lotr it sweeped the oscars?

well if your not going to follow the books why do it? is nothing in Hollywood orginal?

why bother? So you can visually see what the book has told you about. thats why. The books came first not the movies and now the movies say this is what happened and it didnt

thats not the cash cow. I dont think it will ever be since fantasy has taken second place to comic books and to Science Fiction

but we didnt need Cuaron since it was the blue bird Shurken head and Whomping Willow. BUt the goblet DID YOU PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIRE! thats not dumbledore if you read the book Dumbledore is calm its only when he enters the room to capture the fake Mad Eye

for Harry it was successful since it had more marketing nothing more and nothing less.

I didnt read any of those were they good

OH what about I cant wait to walk the halls of hogwarts as a free man and then like nothing oh you know i am your godfather!

and the werewolf is supposed to look like a werewolf not a possum wolf

what about the 3rd Cuaron made it a art film and forget it was about Harry Potter

the 3rd made it that way

Prisoner is not a mystery. Prisoner was about the relationship between god son and god father and that was totally glossed over

Yeah but thats what the crimenals are creepy and evil. Joker cuts his own face off Mister zzazz cuts himself, Two face one side good one side bad etc etc. Penguin is just a crime boss in the books

it was crap thank god Aaron Eackhart made Two face likeable again

HAHA yeah he should have kept his mouth shut over gay people. Fans of the books heck now its 75 percent gay or it seems that way

it showed how evil the Penguin can be.

So instead of creating the wonder we create the dread?

yeah Columbus is getting so much heat and the rest are not? Especially Cuaron and then newell! Everybody in Goblet was angry!

How did Columbus fail HP! if it wasnt for him you wouldnt have gotten the blue bird and Cuaron!

CUARON was the F blue bird and F Yates it was MONTAGE GALORE!!! my god! How the heck was any movie from Prisoner onward a good Harry Potter film who is the real Mad Eye Moody Dumbledore would never lose control like that manhandle Harry Potter! NEVER!