Funny enough I actually think old penny will be back next season as and foil for new penny. Only because, he wasn’t just in the underworld, he was in the Underworld Branch of The Library. And if the Library is being set up to be The villian next season then that makes sense that he would come back.

Eliot meeting Quentin at the end went from hopeful to horrific in 3 lines. I loved it.

Please start covering this show regularly. You gave up during the best season yet. Doesn’t exactly make much sense.

Don’t forget about Marina 23 who oddly just disappeared after “Twenty-Three” despite crossing over with the rest. If she’s not a part of S4, I’d be a little annoyed.

I’m SO glad that the renewal was announced before the finale aired. Makes the wait until 2019 a bit more bearable, knowing that there’s something to wait for.

I hate to brag, but he was an incredible Burr. Part of me now wants a Miranda/Odom Jr Superstar but I don’t think LMM has the vocal chops to pull of Jesus.

Some of those tattoos ARE makeup.

Yeah, Chiaphas’ low end vocals disappeared early on, which sucks cause that’s his character’s whole thing. I think it got better as it went. I detect a bit of Nat King Cole in John Legend’s style which, to be fair, leans toward intimacy rather than bigness. He did pretty good. This show has always been a Judas…

That’s what I figured. Brutal. No family should have to go through that just for a paycheck, let alone watch the man responsible become a goddamn senator.

To some extent I think I’d very literally suffer from some level of PTSD if we saw Biden or Bernie or Hillary or Obama or anyone from the past pop back up on the ticket (thinking Obama as VP in that scenario). I’d still vote because I am a voter, but I can imagine a lot of people would completely lose their enthusiasm.

As someone who thought about suicide and ended up in the hospital because I attempted to kill myself, I’m going to say something that might be extremely controversial. In the hours of crying leading up to my attempt, preceded by weeks and weeks of constant depression, I never once thought, “I’m going to record 13…

How did the Magicians become one of my favorite shows that I look forward to every week?

She’s not allowed to make political statements. William is president of Bafta. Why should she sit out? Can we stop vilifying women who aren’t doing Times Up well enough?

Just so you know, I’d have voted for Bradley Whitford to get two new roles if I could.

Would. Hard.

I must say the scruffy silver/(snow?) fox look is really working for him

Wait, am I the only one watching The West Wing over and over pretending it is real life?

The last ep, before this current ep, when Elliot says “Oh Hi Penny” might be the culmination of an amazing show. Fucking shame on AV Club for not reviewing. This show IS AVclub.

I am loving this season, and it’s really hard not to have this community to read, to enhance my enjoyment of this show. C’mon...surely the Q and Eliot happy family arc deserves your attention!!