I also love Matt.. not because of the way he can act drama or even his fun/ny moments but because of the way he can get every line to have the deepest meaning in the way he can twist the way it's delivered. It's a strange thing but the day I found myself saying the lines out loud and wondering how he came up with the…

Never give up, never give in… :')

What would've been great about that (I'm not sure it's exactly what you meant but…) is……

I agree, I'm still waiting for the show to find it's footing. Meanwhile, I watch because of Mark Pellegrino, he just makes every character he portrays interesting.

In an interview, Moffat sort of implied that he counted meta-crisis as a regeneration. I'm fully expecting it to be adressed in the Christmas special, but if it's not (they're already trying to get so many things in it anyway), I'm expecting Capaldi to have a season of "why did I regenerate past the limit?"

That is quite neat. I hope it was meant that way.

I always thought it was because he wanted to really impress Rose, by going really far out into the future but still having something familiar to ground it. Or something. If you have to think about it though, I would say he wanted to make a connection with her, and this was the best way he could.

I'm loving this reviews, and I'm gonna love the 9th Doctor's era especially after The Day of the Doctor.

Ah well, I was sort of joking too. Sorry if it came off as offensive :)

Ah well, then you're wrong again. But in a sort of wibbly wobbly kind of way.

No, I mean. John Hurt and the Tenth had lost themselves, lost what it was to be the Doctor, as per Clara's definition, I can see that. But when she says Eleven should 'be the Doctor' I saw it as an implication that being the Doctor is more than being a hero. He is more. I doubt Moffat meant it as an insult, he's just…

I disagree. Having him be a fundamentally different character just for the sake of having him there is not good enough IMO. Besides, NotD was excellent.

He's not only a Time Lord, he's the Doctor. He sort of says it himself.

I loved that it implied that the Doctor is more than just a hero.

I've said this above, but anyway haha. I think it doesn't cheapen any of Nine and Ten's experience because fundamentally JHurt did it, and chose to do it. Ten did too. It was all the suffering and the character arc that they went through that got Eleven to 'chage his mind' and do the right thing. To see another way…

The thing is, it wasn't the War Doctor or Tenth Doctor that decided to not do it. It was the Eleventh. When he finally came to terms with what he did, forgot, and decided to 'change his mind'. So that the Ninth and Tenth and most of Eleven had to deal with deciding to do it seems proper to me. It is, after all, that…

That's interesting. Yes, maybe something like "you decide". Cool, very good..

Have you seen "M"? If you have, there's an interesting comparison I would like to make.

My problem with the baggage of Who actually appeared when I learned there was baggage to begin with. Before that I had no problem, but then I found myself watching say Cold War and wondering if that Skaldak had appeared before and if I had missed some of their story.

It survived two viewings. The third time I felt like punching someone..