I can consider all three NuWho Doctor's my first, yet liked Matt Smith's the most.

Alternatively, Moffat could suddenly write normal Who plots and arcs.

@avclub-b9a25e422ba96f7572089a00b838c3f8:disqus  I'm watching Tom Baker right now and he gets pushed around… a lot. So I sort of felt the same way you did I think because no-one ever touches him in NuWho (and I hadn't really noticed that). And it feels very very wrong.

I think it wasn't supposed to make me laugh… was it?

This is just awesome lol

…

That's not racist, in that it's a sort of quadruple negative. By doing that, they were showing they were not afraid to do the stereotypical thing (I swear, I don't even notice these things! What, are "black spacemen" now supposed to be all big balls of peaceful love? The shows's had millions of "white" evil people,…

Why is the fact that a specific character is identified with a specific "race", as everyone seems keen on calling skin colour, racist? He's just always been the white stereotypical British 20/50-something. Deal with it.

It isn't all bad, that's why I was able to mostly ignore those parts that were… Augh, but it isn't close enough that I can say I could enjoy watching it again without shuddering at times and well.. I don't stomach those good enough. I didn't buy how it was resolved, either, even though I reaally tried. And the whole…

Good theory.

Very true. Hmm…

Okay, to hell with it:

Maybe Moffat's episodes because, well, he's Moffat. There I could see you're point. but his season generally have well developed moments which sometimes (I think for any show devoting an episode to one idea and one idea only is a pretty bad decision) focus on only one idea and develop it throughout-fully. Maybe Hide…

I would also really add The Snowmen, and maybe The Power of Three.

I'm sort of expecting it to be Rose and have Clara go "Oh, it's you!" in the Anniversary Special..

Yeah, I'd say "unkillable" was the right way to put it.

I agree with everything except the Silence stuff, mainly because everyone was shouting so it was hardly "silence". IMO, we haven't seen that yet.

3) Add to those stopping or negating the GI and yeah, that's about it.

Because HE's the reason she foils him :)

Not to mention that (while in character) he has gone from goofy to serious, from caring to uncaring, from young to old (character-wise), etc. And he's persistently shown (see: this season) he can show anger, fear, sadness, happiness, loneliness, etc. I think this series can take you places if you let it.