Scrolled through the comments specifically to see if anyone else had thought it was Nick Offerman too, glad to see I wasn't the only one

I get that reviews are subjective, but I'm genuinely amazed that AV Club has been giving this season such high scores every week. I've been disappointed by every single episode bar one this season, and this episode was a hilarious new low.

Suspension of disbelief though - if you want to make something fantastical make it plausible, or at the very least come up with some reason for it that doesn't just sound outright stupid