No, this is simply wrong. Every character you mentioned was beaten up, needed rescuing and was in over his head many times.

Poe is a “great pilot” but he has experience that somewhat supports that assertion. He survived the movie, and maybe he shouldn’t have but whatever, Wedge survived the original trilogy too weirder things have happened. Believable.

Luke survived a battle, which isn’t weird in and of itself since other people were taking…

Every single character in this had lengthy training either in their character backgrounds or on screen. Everybody but Rey.