Wow, this guy is totally full of BS.
If people don't buy things cause they are new and shiny... Then why did anyone at all buy a Wii U, cause at the moment there ain't no great experiences to be had on that new and shiny.

You should probably, no definitely, lose the phrase I peed a little.

If it doesn't have free roam, then I don't care!

Not really the same thing.

While reading this I realize there is a whole community of people that do not think of gaming the way I do.

In the first top three games he recommended for the Wii U he mentions wind waker, over a decade old game?

I really don't think phase iv is in 2d.

I thought that about gta iv. But Max Payne 3's multiplayer was so right. I'm interested in this game a little bit for the open world freedom, but mostly to see what the multiplayer looks like. With crews, and the excellent 3rd person gunplay from MP3. This could be a winner.

I'm looking at those controllers and reminded of the line here by one of the Kotaku writers that stated Microsoft spent hundreds of millions of dollars developing this new controller... And I'm picturing Redmond literally bursting at the seams with bull-shit.

That's reaching for things to complain about to me. It's a great idea, the best of both worlds. Those things you mentioned are minor inconveniences I think.

Wow, and there is still the DLC coming. The PS3 is making it hard to justify a PS4 at the moment. Everything I want is coming to the PS3 this year.

Absolutely, the game was incredible.
The multiplayer was also, much to my surprise, incredible as well.

Now, that I can agree with.

Americans are all to eager to offer their opinions in others. The Japanese are too polite.

I can tell you enjoy the game, but the game you want is not the game I want. I don't think your co-op version fits the narrative at all. It sounds to me that you don't want a dark souls game, you want a co-op game with a medieval or souls like theme that retains some difficulty. I don't see any of the tension or the…

It is really not surprising that an 8 year old with access to a gun, and grand theft auto iv, shot someone.

There is no Co-Op in Dark Souls, if you are playing Co-Op then you aren't playing the game the way it was meant to be played.

You raise a few good points but...
You are wrong.
I know what it's meant to be.
A co-op experience it is not meant to be.

Oh really?
Anecdotal much?

That's because you are looking in the mirror.