I was upset with that one because I was expecting some sort of narrative conclusion to the film.

There's also an extended sequence in Roberta that just makes me roll my eyes over and over again.

Well, technically, she got one.

YES! YES! YES!

"Why, I make more money than - than Calvin Coolidge! Put together!"

As a kid I used to yawn through it, but if you take it as a short little sidetrip it's really entertaining. And despite what people say, there is an in-movie reason for its inclusion.

I was super confused by that. I thought maybe I had accidentally missed five episodes or something.

The episode itself occasionally shows a more nuanced portrayal and I hope that's what they lean into in future episodes.

I think the show could be excellent if instead of slut shaming Eliza they focused on her selfishness. They're two very different things and whenever Eliza's self-obsession showed up it was instantly a better show. They need to make the distinction that using Facebook and Twitter isn't inherently bad, but relying on…

So I loved the first three episodes of the series and absolutely hated Listen and Time Heist. I'm so apprehensive of The Caretaker…

I think it's a little silly to compare seeing a companion as a little kid with seeing the Doctor as a child. Any way you put it, it's a Big Deal because so much of what makes the Doctor as a character interesting is that we theoretically know him so well but so much of him remains a mystery. It's shaky ground to tread…

Clara should absolutely have immense impact on the show. But I would argue that the companion has impact on the current Doctor, which shapes the narrative, instead of the entire show. Sarah Jane had a profound effect on Four, Ace had a very complicated, mature relationship with Seven. Both companions were the Doctor's…

I really want to know why Moffat keeps making Clara the history behind the entire show. I hate the idea of all those amazing things coming from one short-lived companion 52 years into the series.

BUT WHAT ABOUT THE LOOMS

I didn't read the script and I still think this episode was a mess.

Yeah, I thought they'd do something more with that too. Robin of Sherwood is pretty heavy on the religious and satanic iconography, so maybe it was a little shout-out, but why pick the cross and then not say anything about it?

Agreed. Look what it did for Six. I saw Waterhouse at a convention once and he was really charming and self-deprecating and it made me feel bad for hating his character so much.

I remember thinking that I wanted to like Hide, but I just wasn't feeling it while watching.

Honestly, I was hoping we'd get some sort of connection to Robots of Death, because the designs seem fairly similar.

I know many Adric fans.