I specifically said that I come here for reviews that are not just recaps. This was more than a recap, sure, but the critical thesis is moralistic while the argument itself is formalistic, and there's not much work done to show why conflating the two is acceptable. It may be possible to show that, but this review made…

Yeah. I come to the AVC precisely to get reviews that other places would call fussy or nitpicky, but this is beyond the pale.