The problem with Moffat haters encapsulated in one review. An episode written by SOMEONE ELSE (and co-creator nonetheless) and it's turned into yet another petty exercise in Moffat bashing. Well done, you've done a grand job on confirming my personal thoughts on the subject.

No contest. Both are great writers but ONLY Moffat is a great writer of Doctor Who. Frankly, I found much of Davies' era, including his own efforts, embarrassingly poor and rewatching from the distance of time hasn't improved them at all.