Precisely!!! Gee, I'll go back to a place where people know i know shit i'm not supposed to know. That'll go well.

I honestly think this review missed the mark. Bobbie OBVIOUSLY was not going to go back to Mars with Martens. What was there for her? She clearly wouldn't be continuing as a soldier and she KNOWS what she saw. What other realistic option did you think she had? So, I don't get the harangue about this being a writing…

I agree with ThinkerT. I think Guthrie betrayed Mr. Scott (and would have done so whichever way he decided) - I don't think he ever appreciated Mr. Scott's enabling his daughter to be so "successful" - Guthrie really has an inferiority complex. This was a good way to get someone out of the way who would be…

They are on the Walrus. I don't think they had time to get the full crew together for the Ranger. They had to relaunch the Walrus, which they would have done at high tide, and beat feet after the Andromache. Careening was done as swiftly as possible, since the pirates and the ship were REALLY vulnerable.

I think he is pretty big, but Vane is standing on the beach looking up at the guy (I'm still betting he's Blackbeard).