Please stop using this example because every time I have to remember that they killed Jen in the finale and it hurts my heart.

The one thing that bothers me about the future scenes is Joanie's age - she's 18 months old in the finale, the court scenes are happening some time later, but not that far ahead, yet Joanie's seemed younger than 18 months in ep 2 and not exactly acting like a 20-26 month old at Martin's wresting match. I know…

Isn't it funny, he seems less of a jerk in the pov less future? Still a jerk, but somehow less of an asshole?

I do think the scene at the end of ep 2 where he is looking at Joanie is Cole starting to think about the math, but I understand why he wouldn't have before.

Sorry, I just don't see it. It is a discrepancy of fact that Noah remembers Alison in a different dress than Alison remembers wearing and that dress is one in the video.

If they didn't show it, it didn't happen? We didn't see the specific thrust home that conceived Joanie but we know Alison and Cole had sex (and there were plenty of people willing to argue that they hadn't had sex because this show always shows sex and we only "saw" making out). We haven't had a Helen POV since ep 9,…

I'm not sure how the distance between the rowboat and the accident are bad writing, but the other differences make more sense? I don't think that's what you're saying, but I don't quite get it. The show has always done this, there are always always discrepancies that seem impossible to reconcile. I'm not sure how…

Margaret said she was paying for the reception in Noah's POV. I don't find her presence that contrived. And we got nothing of the year between ep 9 and ep 10 from Helen's POV at all. So I don't find her reconciliation with her mother that surprising either.

I feel like I'm in the minority, but I never mind the discrepancies. To me, it's the fun of the show. We all remember things differently, each segment, except the future ones, is the presentation of an unreliable narrator. The versions don't reconcile, but they never reconcile. The objective truth is somewhere in…

If Noah told Helen Joanie wasn't his, why does she ever take Joanie's pacifier at the wrestling match earlier in the season?

Helen wouldn't have to drive out to Montauk, she's apparently attending Cole and Luisa's wedding with Margaret, judging by the preview. She still makes no sense, and I agree I bet it is Noah, but she wouldn't have to go out of her way.

I think that's where we disagree, I don't see Cherry being chill. Or legitimately reminiscing. The whole thread of what she was talking about seemed to me pretty passive aggressive, and I feel like Luisa perceived it the same way. To me, it wasn't unnecessarily rude, it was rude and blunt. But Cherry wasn't, in my…

Luisa was sitting right next to Cole when Max was testifying.

How important is the loony curse to Cole? He was joking about it to Luisa in the car. We've missed a whole year in these characters' lives and unfortunately we don't know for sure, but it seems like at some point Cole and Luisa probably talked about having kids, if they want to, and that there are other ways to be a…

I have people I care about who have toxic as shit relatives, if I were in a position where I was introduced to them, yeah, I would as civil as I could manage but might make a seriously bitchy remark based entirely on only what I've heard about them. Cause I care about the people they were absolutely toxic garbage to.…

It was Alison's POV - I think she saw him as perfectly happy in a way she was not.