How on Earth are they “conspiracy-like strings of information”? Of course the studies regarding the non-hormonal differences between males and females are relevant - as we’ve established, trans women’s hearts, lungs and limbs don’t magically shrink if they start taking hormones after puberty! Again, the sources you…

This is ridiculous! What’s wrong with the the sources I’ve posted about athletic ability? When you posted sources for your claims that testosterone is the only physical advantage that males have over females, I didn’t just dismiss them without giving an explanation - I pointed out that they claimed “medical experts…

Why would my concern for non-binary people be false? I said that the issue of non-binary people was one of the reasons why spaces should be segregated by sex, not gender! If there are more than two genders, it’s not practical to keep segregating places by gender. I understand that trans and non-binary people don’t…

I can’t believe you’re actually asking for evidence that the vital organs affect sport performance, but page 111 of this book is a good start. It explains how skeletal structure gives males a biomechanical advantage, and how heart size and lung capacity are advantageous as well. If you don’t think it’s a reliable…

I brought Danielle Muscato up because you mentioned Buck Angel as an example of why locker rooms shouldn’t be separated by sex! The number of XX people who look like Buck Angel is vanishingly small, too.

I still can’t understand why you think I would lie about being able to identify Laverne Cox as male when I freely said that I wouldn’t be able to do the same for Janet Mock, but whatever. And if you’re honestly going to keep claiming that the vital organs of the human body are irrelevant in sport, I don’t know what to…

Thank you :) I agree with you - I think it speaks volumes that there’s an insult for women who don’t want to give up their rights to their own spaces (TERF), but not for the men of whom MtFs admit to being afraid.

Of course I’m not lying to myself about generally being able to tell the difference between the sexes! Most people can, I’m no different from anyone else. I’ve already said twice that there are some exceptions, like Janet Mock.

Why on Earth would I lie to myself about noticing that Cox and Pejic are biologically male? I’ve already said that there a few trans women, including Janet Mock, whom I would never guess were transgender if I didn’t already know.

Honestly, I think a lot of my high school classmates would just have found it funny. There’s no law that says girls have to wear dresses or make-up, so the boy wouldn’t even have to change his name or appearance or anything. I’m not sure if there exemptions stating that if teachers suspect the student isn’t serious,…

Why is it tiresome? Do you think I was lying when I said that I can tell Laverne Cox and Andrej Pejic are not biologically female? I already said that there ARE some trans people who pass as the opposite sex - I wouldn’t be able to guess that Buck Angel and Janet Mock are transgender just by looking at them. But it’s…

Here’s an article from an LGBT news site. It was one of the first results for “Renee Richards” on Google:

I said that you can USUALLY tell someone’s sex from looking at them. There will be exceptions, like Janet Mock, but those are rare. Humans are sexually dimorphic - males and females have different secondary sex characteristics. The first time I saw Laverne Cox on TV I thought she was a man. I’m not psychic - I can’t…

But you can deal with the issue of people like Buck Angel by treating men’s areas as open-class. As you said, women’s spaces are safer because women are, on average, less violent. The purpose of separating areas by sex is for women’s safety, not men’s. If a trans person passes as the opposite sex, they’ll be able to…

Thank you for answering. Isn’t that unfair to gender-fluid people, though? They can’t choose when their gender changes. I don’t understand how people can say that it’s invalidating for binary trans people to be denied access to facilities of their true gender, but non-binary people are told to suck it up. That’s harsh.

Sorry if I missed this, but if this passes, does anyone know if students will need an official diagnosis of gender dysphoria before they’re allowed to use the restroom of the opposite sex? Otherwise, I can guarantee that at least some of the boys in my class would think it was funny to announce that they’re…