What if new creators appeared on Spider-Man, brought back the black costume and had Spidey became a vengeful killer of criminals who had managed to escape the justice system?

Yes. He wanted to do a book that would be his take on the DC Silver Age and simply imposed it on DD with no concern with whether it would fit (and, of course, it doesn't). For his central character, he offered his take on the poor-man's-Spider-Man version of DD that existed in the strip's earliest days, before it had…

DD has a rather distinguished history of great writers and artists. Frank Miller is the characters' best writer, the one that finally gave the book its unique voice. Denny O'Neil, Ann Nocenti (who had a great, long run that is underappreciated—at least by Marvel), everyone on vol. II except Bob Gale and Andy…

Garbage writing, garbage art. These clowns can't get off the book fast enough.