I really enjoyed this pilot tremendously. I usually fall head first into the trap of wanting 'mystery oriented' television to provide a meaningful resolution to its mysteries, but I can tell already from this pilot that this will not be important for this show. For instance, my favorite thread of the pilot was the…

I don't understand the C rating either, but it was probably inevitable that the show would start shedding some of the adoration once it finally settled into a chosen path. The most widely praised parts of a series as densely layered and ambigous as this are always the middle ones when we can still project how we want…