Oh I do agree. A lot of fans miss that they are not putting much in the way of personal conversations between the two.

Well, not going to say I don't agree with you on the rape scene. EP15 could have probably contained half of the stuff in EP16 and then used EP 16 for other stuff. But I guess where we disagree is I would have used the time for more of the Jamie/Claire dialogue (I hate saying love scene because it doesn't have to be a…

Oh gosh, I am so different then you on this. I, and I would bet most of the audience, could care a less how much doctoring Claire could do. His inner turmoil is the entire crux of the story from here on out. Ron, the producer, says it affects how he thinks of things in all of season 2 and it affects how he thinks of…

Gosh, remember people they had a darn 55 minutes. To do all that Diana does in these books, they would have needed 55 hrs just for this episode. They can NOT every scene and every line that is in the books. And he has explained why they did it differently. They don't have as much time so they had to change it so…

Why would he not be understandable in the end? It is what it is and in the scheme of all the stuff going on in their lives, it has to be put into perspective. Many did not even make it to that stage back then and then often did not survive it. Yes it is a blow to him at first but not the end of the world.