well done. Yes they are the greatest, but let's keep it our little secret.

The Beatles?? That's the best group he could up with? There's no story there…now give me deep introspective into the Spice Girls and I might watch.

Alison Brie was great. You should have mentioned that

I don't think Alana's dead. But I can't say the same for Abigail…which is a shame. Still, it was a very unique twist to find her alive. Next season may be the single best dramatic and horrifying network TV show that has ever been made,This episode alone shows why it's lights ahead over any other show on the 4 major…

I finally caught up and watched this, hesitantly, since the reviewer only gave it a B. I gotta tell you, this is one of my favorite episodes I've watched, and I've watched them all. Lots of Joan, the first time you hear Sherlock say he loved anyone, and a great procedural story overall. Think you guys missed the mark…

Party All The Time was a brilliant choice. So out of left field, and performed beautifully. Eddie Murphy has to be smiling right now.

A+. What a way to end the year. I've watched maybe 5 total shows in the last 2 years, and this was like hooking up with one of your best friends years after you last saw them, and having all the familiarity and all the fun you used to have. So many touching moments…and so well done. Basically, the best show they ever…

What about Rust?

Well, this didn't go well. It seems like he doesn't even know Buckley's gone and that the song's meaning and popularity are directly attached to the sadness of his tragic death. Anyway's, I never heard of these guys and I don't plan on checking them out anytime soon.

Paul McCartney. I'll probably cry for days.

Wow..you graded this a C?? My wife and I have watched every episode, and this one, to us, was very, very good. Watson's storyline was very moving (especially for me, who had a schizophrenic mother and a brother that was an addict…and both died too young.)

that's exactly what I meant. Not trying to compare to every concert I'll ever see…just that is one of the best out of many. Plus, do you think we'll see Ringo do Billy Shears and play drums during Hey Jude again? Maybe…but unlikely.

upvote for Siamese Dream avatar.

Yea, I'm 40 now and have seen Paul live 8 times, including the show from last night. I always have walked away still amazed at how great a performer he is at his age…not just his voice, which sounds like it always did..but his bass playing is still so sharp, and I consider Paul to be the greatest bassist of his genre…

fixed…just woke up, head still foggy (I watch the show 3 times last night) :)

Depending on who you ask, The Beatles are part of “my parent’s generation,” “my kid’s generation,” or “my generation.”

A- ? I was at the actual show, and it ran about 4 hours live…there was a lot of great montages that CBS naturally didn't have time to air. It was great to see that they changed the running time of the show from 2 hours to 2 and a half…that way they were able to air all the musical performances. Anyways, no matter how…

Wow…you gave this a B? I've watched every episode and this ranks in my top-5 favorites, easily. Probably the most interesting procedural they've done yet (and maybe I just say that because I'm a science geek), but we got a lot of Joan too, and it was one of Lucy's best episodes yet.

I was trying to spell 'fudged' but couldn't remember how to do it since I was diagnosed with Type-1 diabetes last month.

Saw True West also. They actually swapped roles every other night. Also got to see him in Shakespeare in the Park's "The Seagull" in 2001 with Meryl Streep, Kevin Kline, Natalie Portman, Christopher Walken, John Goodman, and Marcia Gay Harden. He was an actor's actor and his work on both stage and screen will be…