Yeah, we want Petra. Although the new line up isn't bad either:

Never heard this perspective, but it does make sense. It really is a shame those two could not work it out. For me the "winner" is Matt Sharp.

I need to jump into this conversation. All I here is Rivers, Rivers, Rivers. Although the man is quite cool, I do see the first two albums as a collaboration between him and Matt Sharp, who split with the band after Pinkerton.