Or if it aired on HBO. Can you imagine Lost on HBO?!

Yeah but thats a dumb ass way to explain it when they were only flashing forward to after they were dead for the last season. "They were dead the whole time" would ONLY make sense to explain the flash sideways, and nothing else. I think most people say that referring to the entirety of the series. Which is plain dumb.

I genuinely do not understand how someone with full mental capacity can watch the entire series and walk away thinking they were dead the whole time. 20 minutes to the end of the finale, they LITERALLY say "Everything that happened, happened" and that is the title to one of the final episodes I believe. You're fucking…

Is season 3 the one that opens with the Others view of the plane crash??? Im with you about their daily life, but that sequence of the plane splitting up mid air was breathtaking when it aired.

It was also pretty well established that Rousseu was fucking crazy so maybe she was just too crazed to remember his face.

That is a pretty fair analysis of the final season. It might have been more engaging to watch the Flash Sideways if it was clear what it really was from the get go, instead they shoehorned it in with Juliets sacrifice that was supposed to reset everything, so the Sideways at first appeared to be some alternative…

Lol at this entire exchange.

"We have to back Kate" is fucking classic television.

I find myself wondering if in production the writers were more inspired by what they'd assume would be a Clinton administration or a Trump one…

I liked Garfield a lot and was okay with both of his movies. But I LOVE TH. He's supposed to sound like a teenager! He is one. I dig that a lot.

I loved that.

Yeah okay thats a really good criticism. It would be a lot more compelling to see that then what they are doing.

Yeah I can totally see what you mean about it being a lazy way to connect her with her mom.

Same. Its really tarnished the second half of the season for me. Whats frustrating is I don't think they needed it, I was invested before I wanted to know how Jack died. And honestly wtf kind of death is going to be both believable and satisfying at this point? Get it over with and move on. You don't even have to fire…

Jack and Rebecca's first episode like that was a lot less frustrating given it wasn't the finale.

I think the show would work well if it dropped the Jack mystery and focused on the childhoods and their affects on their adult lives. Kevin and Kate need better storylines I suppose, but I think the shows early episodes that relied a lot less on the death plot shined when they showed things like Kate getting bullied…

Why do you hate Kate?

Why does everyone hate Kate?

did really dig the into the mystic inclusion

I actually wouldn't hate flash forwards to the girls as adults. So long as the big three don't get the awful old person make up that Mandy Moore has to wear.