Reminds me more of the old WWE ring. When Vince McMan would be giving the crowd his speech and the wrestler would seeth in the back, walking around the ring waiting for their moment to respond.

Liquid is the only way top go with the issues you are having. Pencil liners tend to use some form of wax in order to keep the colour in place, oil breaks this down. If you experience transfer from mascara as well, you definitely produce more oil around you eyelid. You may not have oily skin but you can have oily…

I may or may not work for Sephora lol.

I have the exact same issue with my oily eyelids. I hate the UD primer.....it doesn’t do anything to prevent my eye makeup from creasing or sliding all over my face. I highly HIGHLY recommend Nars Smudgeproof eye shadow base. It took me a year to get through a whole tube and I wear full face makeup nearly every day…