I would agree if S1, E1 of the Mandolorian didn’t exist. That episode alone solidified we were dealing with a utter badass. Sure Grogu added the charm that Star Wars naturally has (old school SW, that is...) But it’s when you see Mando just doing things as bounty hunting or even just walking that drips the personality…

TBH, if you look at ANYONE who resembles Boba Fett, chances are that they ARE a knock off.

I’ll do you one better (or worse... really depending on how you look at it.)

This. All of this. ^

There’s demand and interest by the public

Well you know what they say... Insanity is doing the same thing over & over expecting different results.

[Ron Howard voice]: “It did not get the world buzzing with excitement.”

I would love to but... The app isn’t out. And I’ve been dying to play the pokemon tcg on mobile.

TBF, we still haven’t seen anything of the new LOTR show. If this is what it takes to get an adaption of The Silmarillion, then I’m willing to sit through it. 

Same, and by a large margin. It’s possibly the only time I’ve ever laughed and thoroughly enjoyed a Disney film.

Oh absolutely! I’d be extremely remiss to ignore that VERY big factor. ‘Who framed Roger Rabbit?’ tried it with varying degrees of success (and by that I mean that the idea was translated but not done well... at all).

Oh yeah! use that universal healthcare for what its worth. Especially if the pay is in jewels & gems as dwarven miners. they basically have no copay, dontcha know?

*Sigh* I know I’m being baited hard and this wasn’t a serious comment, but I had this exact conversation with someone else earlier this week why they thought it’d be a great live action film. I had rolled my eyes so hard at their logic (or lack thereof)...

Snow White & The Seven Canadians, eh?

I don’t know how well a Oliver & Company remake would work. Especially with how PC things have gotten. There’d be too many changes that it’d end up being a a whole different thing just having the same name. 

Nah, all the dwarves should be played by David Cross but he’s in the Tobias Funke character the whole time. Lmao

That’s what I’m saying! they get Peter Jackson and BOOM! The pentalogy epic will be a hit! Black Cauldron and its universe become household names as it should’ve been. They screwed up that IP so hard that a redemption an proper retelling is in order. And since Disney acquired the rights to the CoP books, making LOTR…

And that isn’t equating when they need to perform the crash safety test. I can’t wait to see the results of THAT possible/inevitable shitshow.

Cal me when Disney has the balls to remake The Black Cauldron.

Yeaaaaaah about that... Uhmmm yeah no. They didn’t do that at all.