You're right it is Amanda.

But Hit List is Off-Broadway. It shouldn't be eligible for the Tonys.
Unless they somehow magically transfer uptown by the cutoff.

This is what I've figured the Hit List plot is from the various bits of the show we've heard about or seen:
Jimmy's character (I can't remember his name) is a talented singer/songwriter from the wrong side of the tracks. He meets Vanessa (Karen), who is apparently some rich socialite with a hidden singing talent,…

HOLY SHIT the shot of Ellis was so confusing that I looked around to the invisible people watching with me to make sure we all saw the same thing.

Who was the first celebrity that McPhee was singing about in Original? It was obvious the 2nd one was Gaga, but I can't figure out the first one.