harper22--disqus
Harper
harper22--disqus

Or episodes with adaptation choices that make sense

I'm happy with good adaptations, excuse me for having standards..

I'd be pissed too if they adapted scenes from my stories with NONE of the context and logic and then a lot of supposedly smart people went on to praise them for being so "edgy" with the material

You're right, the story would have played out closer to the books, which sounds like a genuinely good thing.
And yes she did, she knew he killed her aunt and that he betrayed the Lannisters, AND she had him alone with show!Brienne at her side. Book Sansa would have been well aware of her power over him and used it to

What happened to you saying goodbye? The joke was anemic just like your initial comment, not anywhere near enough to get me angry

The rape was not only completely unnecessary, it completely destroyed Sansa's character arc.
Jeyne's treatment in the books is meant to show off just how evil Ramsay is, but they had already done that by showing off Theon's entire torture.
As for the LF thing, she had full power over him when they met. That was the

Making a cliche Snickers joke is trying?

Its not Edmure's fault D&D didn't want to keep paying Clive Russell

Yeah, 'cause why would you want to actually defend your own bullshit?

Nothing you said was enough to elicit anger, thanks. Next time try to have some kind of a substantive point

Baseless, huh? …. Yeah, I'm not getting into that. For both our sake, that horrible rape scene was totally necessary for Sansa's character development.
If D&D really wanted to make it in anyway feminist, they could've had Sansa accept LF's help the first time, when SHE had all the power. She knew his crimes and he was

How is begging to the person who gave her to her abuser feminist?

Its not at all relevant to the complaints since they have to do with the quality of the show. Whining that you don't have to watch it doesn't erase the bad writing or dialogue.
And in terms of Transformers, I wasn't making an exact adaptation-level comparison, just overall quality. "Where are my niece and nephew? Lets

You need to learn to read. You don't have to watch the show is an obvious and trivial point that in no way deflects how shitty this show is

Its not an inconvenient point, its asinine, its trivial, its obvious. And its also whining about someone's complaint.
And Bay is a director, which means he chooses what goes from the page to the screen

1. Absolutely wrong, they were legitimate criticisms that you just dismissed with the same bullshit point
2. Never said he was a writer. Obviously he has some involvement with the scripts he directs, and he tends to work with shitty writers

People still hate-watch and rightfully criticize the shitty writing and logic, that same, especially if they're fans of the source material.
There's a lot about this episode that can be criticized, the stupidity of Jon's plan, the needless death of Rickon, the Vale knights serving as Deus ex Machina, LF being the

The person you responded to was the one with the valid points, the lack of logic, which you just dismissed with the same old tired "Just don't watch it", just like every Bay fan says to an honest Transformers fan.

Did you miss the fact that this season is an almost an entire retread of the past books, Feast and Dance?
Could they not have fit in Rickon being in Skagos?

That's what shitty writers generally do, so you're probably right.
Here's an idea, how about actually adapting the books?