If you were implying that I’m a fanboy, I’m not sure that’s warranted. I was commenting on a phenomenon of hatred toward Andromeda apparently based on very little, as a carryover from hatred toward things I genuinely enjoyed. I feel my commentary was justified.

I’m assuming I’m not the only one who saw all those clothes NOT on 2B and got embarrassingly lost in thought for a moment.

Yes. Yes it was.

Sarcastic or sincere, I’ll give you a star there for demonstrating my point. Thank you!

Kotaku seems to maintain a smart mix of criticism and enthusiasm. Also, I don’t want to pretend that Andromeda should be exempt from reasonable concern. It just seems to be within my tolerances so far.

As someone who loved the ending of Mass Effect 3 (alien vs. familiar, organic vs. synthetic, transhumanism!), and who also thoroughly enjoyed Dragon Age: Inquisition (twice), I know I’m currently inclined to like a new Bioware game. Bias recognized.

I’m a little shocked to not see Geralt on this list. Is he not brooding enough? Not ever-having-been-married enough?

We’re re-posting this every 6 months?

Yes. Exactly this. You watch high level streamers on this game, and they’re using the language of fighting games to describe how they adjust to the combat, including learning what combos and attacks are “safe,” what can be “punished,” “free” or “optimal” damage, as well as spacing and timing.

Your argument is almost as persuasive as mine.

Knights is the correct choice. I’m reassured Kotaku is a site I can continue to trust.

Does this make the game less fun? Differently fun? The right amount of fun?

I came here only to make sure that you didn’t put Twilight Princess at the bottom.

I have five children. Yes, I know where they come from.

You got my click for the great headline. You got my comment for the excellent writing.

So...does that mean “a” or “b”?

How did Kirk Hamilton end up so nice? I’m assuming either: a) a tragic backstory that has filled him with compassion, or b) a dark and violent secret that he hides behind his musical facade.

I happened to love Shadow of Mordor’s story as a good summer popcorn flick, so I’m not particularly worried.

The writer is making Horizon Zero Dawn, so I think I’ll just wander over there for a while...

I sold the game ten hours in after deciding it wasn’t for me.