Is there a link to this article? Having read the book not too long ago, I would like to see what they say about it.
The movie was nowhere near as good as the book.

I do remember reading that.

I can't remember if or when there was another show like Buffy that mastered the season long story arcs and Big Bads. Not many shows have been able to pull that off since. Not even Lost.

A big mistake that I think will come back to haunt them.

I think I remember Fury saying that the network was interfering because they were afraid of the show getting to Science Fictiony.

The lack of Peter kept you from liking the show?
Though I love Jackson, that has no impact on most people. We know he will be back.

It's fine if you make it up as you go but do it well. Lost did not. Fringe does.

Lost was always this clueless. At least you get eventual payoffs on Fringe.

The Producers had a template from the original Killing series. They solved the mystery in one season but these people decided to do their own open ended season and in the process alienating it's fan base.

It was Fury ass.

This is one of my all time favorite Buffy episodes. I remember seeing this for the first time and seeing that Buffy killed Angel. They never used to kill off regulars on TV programs but they did it here.

I remember reading an article with Fury after he left Lost and he said they were making it up as they went along.

Gas and Sip. Isn't that the convenience store in Say Anything?

I watched it and found it visually great but like the review said, the storyline was all over the place. Does any of it make sense? Nope. 
Nice ass shot.

Dermott's ass was pretty nice. I would give that an A.

I agree. Didn't laugh once.

I thought this episode wasn't very funny. Jokes were overly predictable. Putting the Dog outside in the front yard? Not cleaning the kitchen? Getting hit in the head with a basketball 6 times or more in one half hour?
This show usually does a lot better.

I like this show.
The guy with the abs made me like it even more.

The San Francisco Chronicle gave it a B so not all reviews are bad.

I thought it was the movie with John Travolta.