I really hate the idea expressed by the reviewer and many of the commenters that we're supposed to be rooting for Jenna to want to be with Matty. She's sixteen years old! If she wants to fool around with guys, this is a good a time as any. Why should we want her to settle for Matty? It makes me wonder if anyone here…

@Mytly: Um…no. Perhaps it would have been dishonorable to not marry Jeyne after having slept with her BUT sleeping with her was dishonorably 1) because he VOWED to marry a Frey, and 2) he slept with her before he was married to her. Robb is not an honorable man. Either way he broke his vow and condemned his cause…

Can we seriously stop talking about the whole Stark-honor issue. Yes, Ned died because he was too honorable (and naive) to play the game. But, Robb died because he let his cock make his decisions for him. He was an oath-breaker.

He's really more of a suit-guy than anything.

I was just thinking that I wish we were doing three at a time. First, who can only watch two GG's a week. It's killing me. Second, If we don't make through the whole series I going to DIE. See? On both counts, my life is threatened.

It's amazing how Shonda can make choosing a family to stalk a touching moment between to crazy-ass characters. Almost impressive.

But he's not stuck.  He took real initiative to become the sort of man that would ask Lorelei out rather than just wait for her to notice him. There is the scene where he shows up to apologize to Lorelei for losing it on his "black day" and, of course, the hay bail maze moment where he really acknowledges his role in…

In life, if you don't format things correctly people won't even look at your submission. The format has to be correct to even get a grade in my book.

Sorry, I read you wrong.

Kissing Rory Gilmore is a really great way to improve your career. Dean got Supernatural, Jess got a pilot for his own spinoff (that didn't get picket up) but then got Heroes, Chad Michael Murray got One Tree Hill, and Logan killed it on FNL and now the Goodwife. She's got lucky lips.

Her laugh is one of the best things to have ever happened to sound. It's just exuberant

That's so true Emily in season one looks 15 years older than Emily in season three.

It only derailed her for Fall semester.

The girl that Rory sits next to at the debutante ball is one of the bridesmaids that Logan fooled around with. The woman that plays Jess' dad's girlfriend is also April's mother. And the woman who plays Rory's teacher in S1E1 is crazy Carrie.

IDK, he acted like a dick when Lorelai told him not to try to parent Rory (which is a totally acceptable position) and he started swinging his peen around when Luke was at the house. And who proposes to someone during a fight?

He was bland and dull until he was creepy and possessive.

Yeah! How dare teachers try to get students to follow directions. God knows that's not a useful skill. This is the general cultural attitude that produces eighteen year old college freshmen that can't format a paper or follow simple instructions.

But it's an AP course at one of the most elite private schools in the Northeast.

I read the Crimson Petal and the White because of Emily's description of it in this episode. It's a great book.

My mother is seriously freaked out by photobooth on my macbook. She leaves the room if I try any funny lenses.