““Sperm donation can never be private anymore” is not the point / argument being made by the author of the article, “ is what you wrote.”

“I showed clearly where you said what you said.”

It’s not a nitpick; you literally attributed a quote to me that is not something I wrote. You proved it by showing what I actually wrote.

Not once did I say “The headline doesn’t say what it says.” This is a flat-out lie. You just proved that this quote that you attributed to me is not something I wrote, by showing what I actually wrote.

“You started out there but switched to “The headline doesn’t say what it says.” It’s even in your previous comments.”

previous experiments in the U.S. and Canada showed only a slight decrease in the workforce, mostly due to a parent choosing to stay home with their children.

Headline: Sites Like 23andMe Make Sperm Donation Anonymity Obsolete

“Sperm donation can never be private anymore” appears exactly nowhere in the headline, nor in the body of the article (and no, that claim is not the idea the author is arguing)..

“Sperm donation can never be private anymore” is not the point / argument being made by the author of the article, and the actual point they are making does not assume that the man involved (i.e. the sperm donor) is registered somewhere.

“You’re arguing just to argue now.”

“I made my point. I never tried to convince you or anyone else of anything except the idea that anyone can be found is untrue.” 

““Been rendered obsolete” is the statement in the headline and the article.

The fatal flaw in your argument is the very first line of your initial comment:

Why did you reply to me with this link to your comment? If anything, it undermines your arguments to me.

Don’t know for sure - but if the 23andMe info is correct, we have a good idea which sibling it is. Long story, but the sister who is registered with 23and Me and revealed this information told all but one (male) of us siblings about it (on facebook, of all places) - the one she constantly has an axe to grind with and…

“knowing the members of a family doesn’t mean you know WHO the exact person was that was the sperm donor.”

“They’d still have to tie you, someone NOT on the site, to him.

“Okay, so he wasn’t registered on the site and she found that (apparent) nephew...how then?”

“Because you responded to me as if you didnt’ understand that.”

Well, yes - of course I do.