That was the DA, not a judge.

Yup. That's why I said "as far as Jim knows."

Keep in mind that (as far as Jim knows) the only reason he's alive is that Barbara came back. He was on a suicide run until Falcone gave him an out, and that out was Barbara. Without her, Falcone wouldn't have had a reason not to have Gordon killed.

Okay. When you agree with someone who really likes an episode, it makes it sound like you like the episode to. Hence my asking for clarification. I've seen a number of folks complaining that the AV Club critics are too negative overall, but I accept that you're making a narrower point about nitpicks that are…

So to clarify: Your argument is that the critics are more critical than the fans? I don't see that as a problem. (Also, a B+ is a pretty good grade.)

In the TV show's timeline, the muffins he ate that day were delivered weeks earlier.