Love, love, loved the scene w. the ring, I hope it figures in the season finale, like one of our heroes has it clutched in their hands.My Joanlock shippers heart went pitty pat….

I agree, the dramatic potential of casting John Noble has been wasted..

Will Sherlock now be obliged to bed Joan's half sister? When he found out the truth about Joan and Mycroft, she said"If I had a sister, would you even hesitate to sleep with her?"Fiona better watch out!

On The Middle, Cindy is an annoying character much like Sherlock's girlfriend on Elementary. I would love to see She become a couple with the tree lover, and Axl would be cute with Sue's roommate.

He seemed to be sleepwalking through the interrogation scenes. Maybe JLM is tiring of Sherlock and just wants to resume his movie career.

The whole thing with Fiona is just blah. Not looking forward to next week.

There was a great scene in "Newhart" where Bob Newhart goes into his maids room (she is wealthy, part of the shows quirkiness) and he has to find his way through rack after rack of clothes. I kind of think Joan's room should look like that.

Are you wanting to see Fiona again? I have to state I'm not. In my opinion, she has no chemistry with Sherlock, but I love Joanlock, so I'm prejudiced.

I was very disappointed in this episode. It needed action and maybe Holmes and Watson being scared instead of them on speaker phone giving instructions to the Baskerville. Joan runs why couldn't she have been in danger? Why couldn't they've set the episode in England? I appreciate the fact that Elementary never falls…

They did not kiss, at least not onscreen, but all the important stuff on Elementary happens offscreen. I did not like their relationship, personally hope it isn't developed.

Ship as in, want them to be a romantic couple!

True, but I am a hopeless Joanlocker!

I really hope "May Holmes" isn't resurrected as a disfigured baddy who wants revenge on Morland. That would be so unoriginal.Any ideas where Sherlock spent those missing hours while chewing on the big reveal about mum?

Poor Sherlock needed emotional support last night…crying in Joan's arms would be a great end to the show.

It helps differentiate between BBC Sherlock and Elementary. I doubt we'll ever see JLM in disguise.

Yes they are romantic, but I ship them!

I don't like Fiona, but why introduce her, just to have some enemy of Sherlock kill her? JLM and LL should be giving the showrunner and those writers grief every week.

I think JLM in Elementary never disguises himself so as to differentiate between himself and BBC Sherlock.We'll probably never see him in a deerstalker or flowing great coat either.

You are so right! Like in the previous show, couldn't the writers have had Watson or Holmes go to the coroner, who is supposedly a friend of Sherlock's, and tell him in person, that the murderer had been caught, since he obviously cared deeply for the victim?That conversation was probably off screen too.

Me too! I would love to see her, dressed super sophisticated, with sexy hair, makeup, sitting at a restaurant waiting for Morland, or Moriarty, her bosses!lol