I think it's more similar to The Leftovers than GoT or TWD. There's no instant gratification and stories aren't tidily wrapped up. I think it's more like The Leftovers in that we may not get all the answers we want and it becomes apparent that those answers aren't really what the story is about. And like The…

I looked at Glen's death and how it didn't affect me, then looked at how Hold the Door affected me for days. Literally days. Such a contrast in emotion, for me.

I've thought about Logan being the MIB, too, and that what we're seeing with him is 30 years prior. When that one park guest tried to tell him how thankful he was and how his company had saved his sister's life (or something like that) he shut that down in a real dick way, and I don't think it's a stretch at all to…

I may be wrong here, but we saw the MIB carry Delores to a barn and then, I guess, he left a gun there for her to find in a haystack and her attack is what sends her riding out and coming across William, right? If that's correct (at this point I'm just a spectator who doesn't know what's really happening) then I…

I know there's probably some tie in back to that one episode when Morgan first showed up again and he saw some tree carving and he knew he was on Rick's trail or something, but I don't know if what he was carving in the mailbox matched the carving on the tree. It may be important and TWD just kinda glossed over it,…

They're 'dammit dude, we're not going to keep stopping so you can get off and carve up a mailbox, your ass is gonna walk.'

This was the best episode I've seen in a while and for me it highlights why I find this show so frustrating. They can make good episodes like this one but they can't make good episodes on a consistent basis.

Seems very disjointed, like the guy who thought of making them into complex characters in the show got fired and the rest of the staff was like 'screw it, just kill em.' I think I like the other version better, too, it seems like there haven't been enough marauders who happen to show up and wreak havoc.

Comments=interest=ratings

I'm guilty of nitpicking this show to death when it annoys me, but I think if anyone was going to stop watching when things didn't make sense or seemed kinda far out it would've been long before now.

So dumb, he was just itching to blow something up.

Hmmm, interesting thoughts..

My biggest complaint against this show is that they built these villains up for a few episodes then they were defeated in one.

If we go by how much food Pi said Richard Parker ate, how do they possibly have enough food for the tiger, themselves, and Negan's haul?

How crucial is it to have a real tiger? The tiger got, as you noted, about 60 seconds of screen time so why bother with filming with an animal? And it was sufficient regardless of whether or not it was perfect. And for the average viewer sufficient is sufficient. I personally thought it was alright.

That bothers me more than it probably should. At least age Judith to about 6-7 years old or never show her at all and have a logical timeline of being 8 years into the za if Chandler Riggs is going to stick around as Carl.

Sometimes Gimple and Kirkman look very uncomfortable at those talking dead discussions. Like they don't really believe half this bs and don't like it either but their hands are tied by AMC.

She doesn't want to kill, so she goes off into the world where the only ones left are hardasses and it's kill or be killed. When she was packing her stuff to go I was thinking 'bye'. Let her ass go, move on.

I've read about bits and pieces of the comic so I may be getting the show and comic confused, but didn't Negan scar or burn Dwight in retaliation for leaving? Has that ever been addressed on the show? It seems like it'd be a pretty big motivator for Dwight and maybe explain some of Dwight's actions better if it was…

It annoyed me so much when the walkers ate that horse, and if I remember right there were entrails being strung about. Do these people not understand that a human cannot bite thru horse flesh? Especially a human who's been decomposing for about a year. And how many decomposing humans would it take to take down a…