I dont believe that's true. For example, her point on how HTGAWM avoids turning racism into a plot point but makes sure it's subtly ever-present was a very interesting observation. It just so happens that as of lately, the bad in HTGAWM overshadows the good, and shes far from alone in thinking that.

A reviewer is paid to give their opinion on the thing they are reviewing. They have 0 obligation to be balanced just for the sake of it. Which either way, Kayla is: she does give praise when praise is due to HTGAWM, which you would have known if you didn't scroll directly to the comments section.

I think Annalise getting shot was the shark that got jumped. So yeah, imo HTGAWM has jumped the shark.