When each family member sees the witch, the only real person that could be present with the family member at that time is Thomasin. Caleb in the woods, Mercy and Jonas in the pen, Samuel in the woods - all last seen with Thomasin. The clues are all there. Thomasin is the witch. When she reveals her true intentions to…

Strange film. Thought it was really bad when I watched it and immediately afterwards, - the audience was laughing at parts of it - but it's so full of symbolism that I couldn't help but think about it afterwards. I'm not sure if it really adds up to more than the sum of its part but it has so many parts with…