It's the second season.

And the "Stella!!!" reference to Brando's iconic line in "Streetcar Named Desire"—funny, I admit, but cheap—was intended, I assume, to further mock the shepherd rather than vindicate him.

The quality of writing in the AV Club is very solid. There is, however, a grammatical error in this piece that's worth noting. In the following sentence—"Duff struggles to sell the big comedic scene at the climax of this episode but the dramatic follow-up between she and Sutton Foster rings true."—the prepositional…