Getting lots of rave reviews is Hesitation Marks.  My favorite one said this is the record Radiohead has been trying to make for a decade.

I wonder who's more jealous of Trent's influence and staying power, Billy or Courtney?

Looking through the list it occurs to me that the reason Pitchfork suck so bad is that they just have shitty taste in music.

Yeah but he said HM is inferior to the much better The Slip in his opinion, of course he only gave The Slip 7.5. The next NIN album will get slagged as being inferior to the landmark HM. Just you wait.