Sorry, I should have explained myself better.

Totally agree. The Hook scene should have been in March. I am positive it was thrown in to get us to come back though. A lot of people might have taken that as a series finale otherwise.

The blue fairy thing is definitely ridiculous. The rest are not holes. They were not well explained and lots of people misunderstood, but not holes. The curse was taking everyone and everything that didn't belong in this world back to the enchanted forest. It had nothing to do with how they got there (Hook, Tink,…

I thought they did a decent job of explaining that. They showed Henry's birth scene again, and it was almost exactly the same but at the last second Emma changes her mind and asks to see him. It's pretty logical to assume that was the moment the memories changed. If her past had changed too, why was she still giving…

Probably. The mad hatter actually referred to them in a season 1 episode. I think he was trying to obtain them for Rumple but someone got away with them (Dorothy, I assume).

I'm more inclined to forgive Rumple because of the dark curse. He seemed like a decent person before he became the dark one. He made some stupid decisions in an effort to save his son. Had he never been the dark one, he wouldn't have become a villain. It was still definitely his fault but he has a better excuse than…

Regina made a blanket curse that took everything and everyone who didn't belong and left this world as if they had never been here, BUT they were. The timeline didn't change. Whatever happened in the past 2 and a half seasons, still happened. Emma was the only one from the enchanted forest who could stay because of…

Lol cuz Regina is still calling the shots here, she made the fake memories so she sure as hell isn't going to change his name.

They have actually shown a similar thing happen twice - Charming tried to kiss Snow after she used the forgetting potion and she tried to knock him out. Rumple tried to kiss Belle when she was in hospital after going over the town line and she flipped. Both are "true love" couples but if one doesn't remember the…

Yeah, I will give you that. But the plot of this show is always a little bit convenient like that. I usually ignore the minor points, especially for scenes with great acting and I would say this one had plenty… so I give some things a pass. I still see no evidence that he cut it off and he flat out said he had no…

I understood Henry dying being different because Pan was actually using Henry's heart. We have seen people's hearts be out and kept locked up or what have you but never inside another person's chest like that.

No. He didn't cut it off. They specifically showed that he was still wearing it and he flat out said he had no magic. At no point in the scene did he use any magic (the shadow and the dagger may have made it seem like he was, but he didn't perform any magic himself). The scene with the sword was him struggling with…

Regina was simply recycling the curse on the scroll… Because of time constraints, she could only alter it so much, but the point was that she had to take everything and everyone who didn't belong in this world with them, so
it was if her curse never happened here. Emma being able to stay was a loophole that Regina was…