Yeah, I was wrong on agreeing that all Stark children are summer children, because they're not. We get that quote in the books told by Old Nan, only to Bran, he is indeed a summer child, he was born in 290. Rickon and Arya have lived all their childhood during the summer, so they also are. The others? Robb, Jon,…

Fine, I'm not absurd, give me a quote to prove I'm wrong.

Yeah, she has 200.000, maybe even more. I mean, let's say 100.000 Dothraki, 10.000 Unsullied, 70.000 from the Reach, 30.000 from Dorne… yup, that's about right. Napoleon for example in Russia had over half a million soldiers… but still he lost, defeated by the huge distances, by winter, by a stubborn enemy that wasn't…

Well, for me it was pretty clear that she was going to destroy everyone with wildfire… of course for this I used knowledge from the book. In the show they didn't even bring it up until episode 8… but they pretty much confirmed it in Episode 9, through Tyrion. You just need to pay attention. The only things I wasn't…

Yeah, good questions… I'm guessing he does find out, but nothing more, very few people will know. I'm kind of mixed on if he survives the story or not… if he doesn't than who cares anymore? Can a resurrected man even have children anymore? I mean he has a punctured belly even now :)

The seasons might be magical, the crops are not :)). Of course nothing grows in winter, WTH? :)) We have plenty of stories of what happens in the North during long winters: people die. Winterfell is probably one of the only exceptions because they use thermal waters and greenhouses. But that's enough probably for…

He's not fighting for a throne, sure, but his nobles, the Vale and the Riverlands might thing differently. Jon himself has very little power, he doesn't have his own power base, he doesn't have a personal Stark feudal army… all his power rests on the other nobles and their soldiers. For example on the Royces and…

Oh I disagree, foreshadowing can work wonderfully on TV and in movies… if it's done right. Just look at The Sixth Sense… hell, many TV shows these days try to do it with various degrees of success. But you need subtlety when you write the script…. Benioff and Weiss don't really have it :).

We know for sure how long was the last summer: 10 years, 2 months and 16 days. It started in 288. Jon and Robb were born in 283, we don't know what season it was… probably spring. Anyway, when Dany was born a year later, it was already summer…. It's simple logic if this summer started in 288, than sometime between 284…

You're again going by assumptions that can very well be wrong. You say he has no hope of winning against Dany. Why? Winter is here. The Vale has not been touched by war and they are the most fertile kingdom in Westeros (comparable with the Reach). They will have supplies to last the winter… especially because they…

Yes they are, so?? They haven't known true winters, but they did experience a winter during their lives. If a winter is usually 1-2 years, a succession of spring, summer and autumn is what? 6? And that's if the seasons are still equal in this world (I think they're not, there are known springs and autumns that were…

Dornish law says noting about polygamy …. sure, they have paramours, but it's not OK to have multiple wives. As well as it's not OK to have affairs once you're married. Not for the women at least. They're more free spirited, but it's still a Medieval world and the idea of heirs is just as important as anywhere else.…

That document will be essential in the book for him being named king… in the show they already did it, so it's become pointless.

You're confusing stuff… he's not a Blackfyre, that's a separated family of it's own. They took that name for themselves. As a Targaryen bastard, born in King's Landing, he would be a Waters. Born in Dorne, he would be a Sand. But where he was born doesn't matter that much….. the name comes from where he grows. So,…

It's simple…. Westeros doesn't get the word, it's just an Easter Egg. Even if some tried to spread this news…. most wouldn't believe it. As I'm sure nobody believes Jon's been resurrected.

Nope not really, not if you read the books.

Hmmm, were some book readers really surprised by anything in this episode?? They shouldn't have been… Cersei burning down the sept?? it's been foreshadowed a lot in the books, although my guess is that it will be worse there. As for Sansa, it's obvious she'll end up in the same place, but the way to get there, her…