Yeah, that theory is dead. Know I'm interested in the Diamonds lore, why Pink Diamond had only 1 planet? Was it because she was the youngest? Are diamonds that rare? Why are they the only ones allowed to individuality (Pink Diamond, Yellow Diamond, etc. against the hundreds of Pearls and Rubies)? What happens if the…

I want to add my grain to the paranoid i can't let go RQ is PD theory: Pink Diamond mural resembles a lot to Rose's and Steven's speed controled landing.

Yeah, maybe she was younger than the other diamonds. So they are not all equal. Maybe the creation of a diamond takes a lot of energy and thats why they're so few OR *puts his tinfoil hat* they are chosen from the best gems to become diamonds.

Yes, but when she met Rose and Pearl she felt scared. The death of a diamond by a Quartz should be HUGE. Diamonds are the "most perfect beings", at that time Garnet should have at least heard about it. Plus Matt Burnett laughed at the idea of a Diamond poofed (but this could be he messing with us).

I mean, Jasper just told us thats what Rose do: go for gems at their top bottom, but if Lion is Pink Diamond and Rose did "shatter" her, why would he helped Steven or hold things for Rose?

I think so too. Maybe she remembered something Rose told her about Pink Diamond and realized it was a lie.

Actually I think they didn't know. When Steven looked at Garnet she seemed surprise trying to get visual confirmation from Pearl about the thing they just heard. I think if they knew what followed, one of them (probably Pearl) would have tried to stop the Ruby.