Read the interview with Jay. His version of events and why the details of the story kept changing make total sense to me. Mainly, he was dealing a lot of weed during the drug crackdown of the 90's out of his grandmother's house. Adnan showed him Hae's body at his grandmother's house, so he didn't want cops searching…

I agree, Nip/Tuck and Glee had great first seasons and then quickly devolved. But, AHS only has one season per storyline, so we get the insane but still fun first season without worrying about continuity, killing off great characters/actors, etc. It's the best format possible for Ryan Murphy's ADD.

The pedant in me is breaking through…. To be bemused means to be confused, not amused.
I'll see myself out.